All terms

CRO Glossary

PICK Chart

A 2x2 prioritization matrix that sorts test ideas by Payoff and Ease into Possible, Implement, Challenge, and Kill quadrants.

A PICK chart is a lightweight prioritization tool used to sort a backlog of experiment ideas along two axes: expected payoff (impact) and ease of implementation (effort). Plotting each idea onto the resulting 2x2 grid produces four quadrants, usually labeled Possible (high payoff, hard to do), Implement (high payoff, easy to do), Challenge (low payoff, hard to do), and Kill (low payoff, easy to do). Teams scan the chart and work the Implement quadrant first, since those ideas offer the best return for the least effort.

Practitioners like PICK charts because they force a quick, visual, low-math triage before investing in more rigorous scoring frameworks. Unlike weighted scoring systems, it doesn't require agreeing on numeric scales or confidence estimates, which makes it useful early in a program when the team hasn't yet built shared calibration for scoring impact or effort.

For example, a growth team brainstorming twenty checkout improvements might place "remove a redundant form field" in Implement (easy, likely to reduce friction) and "rebuild the entire checkout flow with a new payment provider" in Possible (high payoff but a multi-quarter engineering effort). The Kill quadrant might catch a minor copy tweak on a low-traffic page that isn't worth the meeting time to discuss further.

The main limitation is subjectivity: without data backing the payoff and ease ratings, two people can plot the same idea in different quadrants. Many teams use a PICK chart as a fast first pass, then apply a more rigorous framework to whatever survives into the Implement and Possible quadrants.

Related terms

See this in the wild

ABWatcher watches how top teams apply pick chart.

Live A/B tests at 1,000+ high-converting brands, with plain-English hypothesis and takeaway.